Introduction
A number of court cases have surfaced that highlight the difficulties and nuances of judicial involvement in personal legislation. In Mary Roy V. State Of Kerala[9] case where it addressed identical entitlement to inheritance for Christian women. The court’s decision in this instance established that no personal law could override the Indian Constitution, and any provision that did so would be null and void.. Similarly in the case of T Sareetha V. Venkata Subbaiah[10] the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955’s Section 9 was declared unconstitutional by the court on the grounds that forcing someone to engage in non-consensual sexual actions is extremely degrading and goes against Articles 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution. Similarly the court has interfered and over reached in the cases of Indian Young Lawyers’ Association v State of Kerala[11], Shah Bano Case[12]and Shayara Bano V. Union Of India[13]. The study looks at these cases and analyses the debates, discussions, and ramifications that surround them.
One well-known case[14] with significant constitutional ramifications is the Sabarimala temple access issue, in which the Supreme Court rendered a decision which over turned personal law of Lord Ayyappa’s devotees as a separate religious denomination. This case highlighted the need to carefully consider the limits of judicial interference in personal laws by sparking a national conversation about how to strike a balance between judicial power of determining the essential practices and religious practices.
The natural difficulty that judges have in comprehending intricate religious subjects is a crucial factor to take into account in the situation of determining the essential religious practices. It is difficult to understand the complexities of faith, tradition, and religious rituals for the judges who have no background knowledge of the religious scriptures, customs and traditional logic of the particular religion; this creates significant concerns, concerning the proper role of the judiciary in areas of personal law.
Sections 45 to 51[15] and Section 73 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, regulate the acceptance of expert testimony in court proceedings. Historically, these clauses have covered a wide range of topics, including science, art, foreign law, handwriting, and fingerprint analysis. One notable omission from these standards is the provision of professional opinions on religious and personal law concerns. In light of the current social and legal context, expert like pandit’s, maulvi’s or clergy’s opinion should be taken into account when discussing the notion of necessary religious activities, especially where theological nuances play a significant role in the legal discussion. It will be unreasonable to decide the essentiality of religious practices without an expert opinion. With the goal of providing insights and suggestions for future reforms in this important area of legal and social debate, this study aims to advance knowledge of the limits and ramifications of judicial action in personal laws and examines various court rulings to demonstrate how religious freedom is negatively impacted by the essentiality test.
[1] Larcen, G.J. (no date) Religion & Personal Law in secular india. Available at: https://casi.sas.upenn.edu/sites/default/files/iit/Religion%20%26%20Personal%20Law%20in%20Secular%20In dia%20-%202001.pdf (Accessed: 07 November 2023).
[2] Tiwari P, ‘India’s civil code: A source for ideological disputes’ (Al Jazeera, 25 December 2015) <www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2015/12/25/indias-civil-code-a-source-for-ideological-disputes> accessed 7 November 2023
[3] https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2015/12/25/indias-civil-code-a-source-for-ideological-disputes
[4] President Droupadi Murmu, “Religion Occupied Key Place in Social System Since Time Immemorial: Prez”, Business Standard, Mar. 03, 2023, available at: https://www.business-standard.com/article/current- affairs/religion-occupied-key-place-in-social-system-since-time-immemorial-prez-123030300686_1.html (last visited on Oct. 25, 2023).
[5] Srivastava, D. K. “PERSONAL LAWS AND RELIGIOUS FREEDOM.” Journal of the Indian Law Institute 18, no. 4 (1976): 551–86. http://www.jstor.org/stable/43950450.
[6] The State of Bombay vs. Narasu Appa Mali (24.07.1951 – BOMHC) : MANU/MH/0040/1952
[7] Maniyar Z, ‘Personal Laws Vis-à-Vis Fundamental Rights, Part III of the Constitution’(CJP, 30 November 2022) <https://cjp.org.in/personal-laws-vis-a-vis-fundamental-rights-part-iii-of-the-constitution/> accessed 11 November 2023
[8] MANU/SC/0136/1954 The Commissioner, Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras vs. Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar of Sri Shirur Mutt. (16.03.1954 – SC) : MANU/SC/0136/1954
[9] Mrs. Mary v. State of Kerala, 1986 AIR 1011, 1986 SCR (1) 371
[10] T. Sareetha v. Venkata Subbaiah, AIR 1983 AP 356
[11] Indian Young Lawyers Association v. The State of Kerala, 28 September, 2018, Supreme Court of India
[12] Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum, 1985 AIR 945, 1985 SCR (3) 844
[13] Shayara Bano v. Union of India, 22 August, 2017 Supreme Court of India
[14] Indian Young Lawyers Association v. The State of Kerala, 28 September, 2018, Supreme Court of India
[15] Indian Evidence Act, 1872