Central Repository Institute of Legal Education (ILE) Scholarly Publishing Network • Peer-Reviewed Academic Journals
test

test

An International Peer-Reviewed Open Access Scholarly Journal • Published by Institute of Legal Education
CODE: TEST ✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access
Home › Publication Policies › Journal Policies › Review Policy
Academic Rigor • Double-Blind Peer Review

Peer Review Policy & Evaluation Methodology

test (TEST) • Official Peer-Review Protocol of Institute of Legal Education

1. Principles of Double-Blind Peer Review

test is dedicated to maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity, legal scholarship, and objectivity. All submissions undergo a rigorous, independent Double-Blind Peer Review process. Under this standard:

  • The identity of the author(s) is completely concealed from the peer reviewers throughout the entire evaluation workflow.
  • The identity of the assigned referees is strictly confidential and never disclosed to the authors or public readers.
  • Referees evaluate manuscripts purely on merit, doctrinal depth, originality, methodology, and jurisprudential contribution.

2. Three-Stage Editorial Evaluation Process

Stage 1: Preliminary Desk & Integrity Screening (Desk Evaluation)

Upon submission via the editorial portal, the manuscript undergoes desk evaluation by the Managing Editor. The submission is checked for adherence to journal scope, word count guidelines, Bluebook footnotes, and subjected to automated similarity screening via PlagAudit / Turnitin. Manuscripts with similarity exceeding 10% or lacking proper references are immediately returned or rejected before referee assignment.

Stage 2: Double-Blind Expert Review (Referee Assessment)

Anonymized manuscripts passing Stage 1 are dispatched to two independent external subject matter specialists (law professors, senior advocates, or doctrinal legal scholars). Referees independently evaluate the work utilizing the journal's standardized 100-mark evaluation rubric within 48 to 72 hours.

Stage 3: Editorial Board Determination & Final Verdict

Based on referee recommendations, the Editorial Board makes one of four final determinations:
• Accepted without revisions: Manuscript meets all criteria and enters production typesetting.
• Accepted with minor revisions: Authors must address formatting or citation corrections within 3 days.
• Major revisions required: Substantive arguments require refinement and re-review.
• Rejected: The submission fails to meet originality, depth, or methodological thresholds.

3. Official 100-Mark Evaluation Rubric

Reviewers evaluate submissions against an authoritative scoring rubric totaling 100 points. A minimum qualifying score of 60% is required for acceptance consideration:

Evaluation Criterion Max Marks Assessment Parameters
1. Originality & Novelty 20 Marks Authenticity of the research question, innovative legal arguments, departure from repetitive literature, and value addition to existing legal discourse.
2. Legal Substance & Analytical Rigor 25 Marks Depth of statutory interpretation, critical analysis of judicial precedents, identification of legislative lacunae, and strength of legal reasoning.
3. Research Depth & Methodology 20 Marks Doctrinal or empirical methodology soundness, breadth of primary and secondary sources examined, and comparative legal frameworks where applicable.
4. Structure, Coherence & Style 15 Marks Logical paragraph transitions, clear headings/subheadings, academic grammar, formal scholarly tone, and precise legal terminology.
5. References & Uniform Citations 20 Marks Strict adherence to Bluebook (20th / 21st Edition) footnoting, presence of compulsory end references, pin-point citations, and absence of broken links.
TOTAL SCORE 100 Marks Qualifying Acceptance Benchmark: ≥ 60 Marks

4. Turnaround Timeline & Decision Notification

The Editorial Board ensures a fast, professional review timeline. Review decisions and referee feedback are communicated to corresponding authors via official email within 48 to 72 hours of verified submission. Accepted manuscripts are allocated an Article Identification Tag (AIT) and scheduled for immediate periodical publication.